Investor lessons are valuable insights and knowledge gained from the experiences and mistakes of many others. Investing in stocks can be unpredictable, and making the wrong choices can result in substantial losses. Let’s take a trip down memory lane and explore the stories of the ten fallen heroes of the Indian stock market.
The Context
If you are a regular reader of this blog, it won’t be news to you that investment values can fluctuate.
According to popular knowledge, patience is essential when it comes to investing because panicking over a decline in stock value can be harmful in the long term, but what if you initially choose the wrong stock? We have created a list of unusual and peculiar financial stories that have grabbed headlines in the last 5 years.
These stories act as a warning of how many investors have lost significant amounts of capital due to inadequate risk management practices such as diversification and lack of diligence while picking certain stocks. By taking lessons from these events, you can avoid similar pitfalls in the future.
This handpicked assortment from the recent past features the top 10 fallen heroes of the Indian stock market, which were once considered success stories but ultimately fell short.
Note: Our selection criteria are based on the market cap declines experienced by these stocks during the peak of their downfall.
1. Cox & Kings Limited
Cox & Kings, a prominent Indian travel operator, suffered a decline of over 99.40% in market capitalization in 2019 due to high debt and losses from poorly performing subsidiaries.
The company had a successful history and ambitious expansion plan, but its leveraged buyout strategy led to financial distress. Cox & Kings struggled to manage new businesses without prior experience and failed to adapt to technological advancements, leading to a cash crunch and the sale of many assets.
The company defaulted on loans and was found to have falsified financial records, leading to its declaration of bankruptcy. One of the investor lessons learned from this collapse is the importance of balancing ambition and financial stability and maintaining transparency and integrity in financial reporting.
2. Talwalkers Health clubs
Talwalkars Healthclubs India (THIL) was a Mumbai-based fitness center chain, operating over 200 locations across India. THIL provides a variety of fitness and wellness services, such as gym memberships, personal training, yoga classes, and nutrition counseling.
However, THIL suffered a significant loss of market capitalization, a nearly 99% decline in 2019 due to several reasons, including a slowdown in the Indian economy, mounting debt, and increasing competition from newer and more economical fitness centers.
The company’s promoters also faced allegations of insider trading, as they had sold their shares in the company shortly before the news of the default became public. Additionally, there were concerns regarding the financial health of the company, with several of its subsidiary firms facing insolvency proceedings.
This led to a drop in investor confidence and a subsequent decline in the company’s stock price. THIL’s market capitalization fell from over INR 700 crores in 2018 to around INR 250 crores in 2019. One of the investor lessons learned from the downfall of Talwalkars Healthclubs India is the importance of adapting to changing market conditions and competition, while also managing debt and maintaining financial stability.
3. Geetanjali Gems
Geetanjali Gems was an Indian jewelry manufacturer and retailer that was embroiled in a major financial scandal in 2018. The company’s founder, Mehul Choksi, fled the country after being accused of fraud and money laundering.
The company’s stocks plummeted to the tune of about 99%, and it was ultimately declared bankrupt. It’s said that they inflated their financials by taking loans from various banks using false documents, and as a result, their stock price collapsed, and investors lost a significant amount of money. The scandal led to a loss of investor confidence in the Indian stock market and highlighted the need for better corporate governance and regulatory oversight.
4. Manpasand Beverage
Manpasand Beverages is an Indian fruit juice manufacturer and distributor that faced financial irregularities and accounting fraud, leading to a sharp drop in its stock price by about 98% during 2018 and subsequent delisting from stock exchanges.
The investor lessons learned from his downfall is that investors need to exercise caution and perform thorough due diligence before investing in companies, especially those with a history of questionable financial practices.
5. Reliance Home Finance
Reliance Home Finance Limited was a part of the Reliance Group, one of India’s leading private sector conglomerates. It was a non-banking financial company (NBFC) focused on providing a wide range of housing finance solutions such as home loans, loans against property, and construction finance.
The company also offered other financial products and services such as insurance, mutual funds, and wealth management. Its services were primarily targeted toward the affordable housing segment of the Indian market.
In the year 2019, Reliance Home Finance stock in India witnessed a significant decline of about 97% in its share price due to liquidity concerns and a delay in debt repayments, leading to credit rating downgrades and investor panic.
Investors in this stock learned the lesson of the importance of closely monitoring a company’s financial health, especially its debt and liquidity position, before investing in its stock.
6. Reliance Capital
Reliance Capital, a financial services firm in India, suffered from severe financial turmoil due to mounting debt and liquidity concerns, resulting in a significant decline of about 97% in its stock price, while allegations of fraudulent transactions further eroded investor confidence.
The company underwent a massive restructuring, including divestment of assets and businesses, to reduce its debt and improve its financial position. This event highlighted to investors the significance of monitoring debt levels and corporate governance practices of their invested companies.
7. Yes Bank
Due to a significant increase in bad loans and a lack of sufficient capital to cover losses, Yes Bank, a private sector bank in India, experienced financial distress which caused worries about the bank’s solvency and led to a steep decline of about 97% during 2020 in its stock price.
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) stepped in to rescue the bank and imposed a moratorium on withdrawals, which further eroded investor confidence. As a result, the bank underwent a massive restructuring, with new leadership and an infusion of capital from outside investors.
Investors learned the importance of monitoring a company’s financial health and governance practices and the risks associated with investing in banks, particularly those with higher levels of bad loans and inadequate capital buffers.
Despite disregarding the time value of money, a few optimistic investors are still attempting to invest in Yes Bank, hoping for a short-term rebound.
8. Kridhan Infra Limited
Kridhan Infra Limited, a construction and engineering company in India, faced financial distress due to high debt, slow project execution, and delays in receiving payments from clients. As a result, the company’s stock price declined by about 96% in 2018, leading to the erosion of investor wealth.
One of the investor lessons learned by Kridhan is the importance of monitoring a company’s debt levels, project execution capabilities, and cash flow management practices before investing in them.
9. Mcleod Russel India
Mcleod Russel India, a tea producer, faced financial distress due to a high level of debt, declining tea prices, and labor issues. The company’s stock price declined significantly, leading to an erosion of about 96% of investor wealth.
The company also faced allegations of financial irregularities and corporate governance issues, which further dented investor confidence. As a result, the company was forced to sell off assets and undertake debt restructuring to reduce its debt burden and improve its financial position.
Investors learned the importance of monitoring debt levels, corporate governance practices, and industry-specific factors while making investment decisions. They also realized the risks associated with companies operating in cyclical industries.
10. Sical Logistics
Sical Logistics, an Indian logistics services company, faced financial distress due to mounting debt and a slowdown in the economy. This led to a decline in its stock price to the tune of about 99%. The company also faced challenges in restructuring its debt, leading to further concerns about its financial health. As a result, the company underwent a debt restructuring process and divested some of its businesses to reduce its debt burden.
Investors learned the importance of monitoring debt levels and the financial health of the companies in which they invest, as well as keeping an eye on the economic conditions that could impact the company’s performance.
Conclusion
Although this list is limited to the top 10 stock fiascos, similar stories can be seen with other companies like Dewan Housing & Finance Ltd, Sintex Industries, Jet Airways, Reliance Communications, Reliance Power, PC Jeweller, or Zee Media Ltd.
From analyzing these collapses, it’s clear that investors should be cautious and consider several factors before investing in a company. These factors include monitoring the company’s debt levels, corporate governance practices, and financial statements. Self-directed investors should also keep an eye on news and media reports that may impact the company’s stock price, and avoid blindly following market trends and rumors.
Instead, conducting thorough research and performing due diligence before making any investment decisions can help mitigate risks associated with stock investments and lead to profitable decisions for long-term financial success.
Enroll in one of our carefully created courses if you’re eager to learn more.
Our goal is to support you in achieving financial success. To help you improve your financial knowledge and reach your financial goals, we have provided a range of helpful information and other resources on this site.
